Rogue application - Valhalla

shadowrunner · Uncommon

Rogue application

Pizzker · Rare

full on rogues

/vote no

Sige · Uncommon

Full sorry

/Vote No

iliopsoas · Artifact

You have clearly stated that you want to be in valhalla for the friendship so not further questions about that

We may be full on rogues, but if that is not an issue I vote yes.

Skuggan · Common

I think shadowrunner has learn a lesson and wont leave us again :)

And he is a good and active player.

/vote yes

Vexxen · Rare

vote yes

KrullSwe · Uncommon

Hope u realize ur mistake....

/vote YES

locko · Common

you are a good rogue but i think we are full rogues

so i vote /no

Bigbobo · Artifact

I think i am one of the people that reacted most negative about the people who left tbh...i just got some withering memories back ..but i know you´re a nice guy, good player, active and ex-valhalla member...so i vote for trail IF we need a rogue ...i wanna see you´re dedicated to us and only us mate

vote for trial

-- Edited by Bigbobo at 23:24, 2006-10-25

Szambonurek · Epic

sry to say that, but we're full on rogues... /vote no

Grakhh · Epic

If we need more rogue's i vote yes. Good player, funny guy.

But as many say, we have pretty many rogue's. It's up to Apop to decide about the rogue issue.

Quinnan · Epic

Well i heard it was 3 rouges today.

And on out current Signuppage there are 4 rouges signed for the next raid and that kinda to few!!!, ex 7 wellgeared rouges is really nic edps and it helps alot in the bwl fights: Razor, Vael, Broodlord........ So id rather see shadow be the extra rouge that might have to skip a raid IF we are full, and that will ease some of the aggro i know some of you feel.

Imo id really like to take this mate back!

1.Because he is a very close mate to me and ( Reko, krull and Karlgustav we kinda live in the same village)

2. He has the best activity ive seen so far in Valhalla and the overall best dps mostly top three every raid. (Remember when he left he left with 120 DKP and didnt take a single item since the reset.)

3. So i think its time to forgive him, and for me its honarable that he takes a step back in progress to be and play with his friends.

Sige: dunno how you can state your opinion here since you have only raided a few times with us.

I think he deserves a second chance!

// Quinnan

Ashibala · Hekate´s Bitch

Of the people that left us a while back for betrayed there are 2 that I could consider giving a second chance. And I would mainly do it because they had been part of Valhalla for a long time and also been dedicated to the guild. If they can show us the dedication again and realize that leaving valhalla "because we were not progressing" was their biggest mistake ever in their wow career I am willing to take them under our wings again.
Shadowrunner is one of these persons.

/vote yes

Gervantes · Epic

Since he is imba and I only heal imba players, lets take him back so I can get use of my mana!

Sige · Uncommon

Quinnan wrote:

Sige: dunno how you can state your opinion here since you have only raided a few times with us.

I think he deserves a second chance!

// Quinnan

I dont know this guy but the lock number in the guild is enough imo, but i agree that you know more about the situation and what we need.

Hekate · The big kahuna

Sige wrote:

I dont know this guy but the lock number in the guild is enough imo, but i agree that you know more about the situation and what we need.

Uhm.. well hes a rogue

I understand that one would prefer to play with irl-friends, but on the other hand, why do ppl only realize this when their new guild disbands?

And we do have quite a few rogues, but then again, Shadowrunner is a great player. Its up to our rogue class leader. Vote neutral-postitive.

-- Edited by Hekate at 08:15, 2006-10-26

Reko · Common

Think he has learn his lesson, and he know how to play so:
Vote Yes.

-- Edited by Reko at 12:36, 2006-10-26

Naeg · Rare

He is good active player and nice guy, but just on principle i vote no.
dont wanna encourage this kind a manners.
leaving guild to join other cuz they are "better" and if something go wrong still have old "crappy" guild to raid with.
but realy nothing against shadowrunner and if he join us ones again

-- Edited by Naeg at 13:19, 2006-10-26

Damericus · Epic

OMG are you going to leave me alone in "Muffin Vendor"?

apoptygma · Epic

/vote no, based on guild policy not to take renegades back. Apart from that everything else is irrelevant.

Apop

iliopsoas · Artifact

apoptygma wrote:

/vote no, based on guild policy not to take renegades back. Apart from that everything else is irrelevant.

Apop

I have not heard of this policy, but if it exists, it's case closed. Though 2 other officers posting in this thread do not mention this policy.

Bigbobo · Artifact

i cant find that policy anywhere on the page but i feel its common sense to not let people guildjump to much ...but there is always cases when you should see past this rule.. i´ve been thinking abit more about this application and i think its time to give him a second chance..i think i can give him my trust again :)

-- Edited by Bigbobo at 00:13, 2006-10-27

smygelfh · Artifact

It's not an official policy (yet), but of course it's a general policy that if you leave once it's quite normal to suspect that that player will leave again.

However, a policy can have exceptions. We do have the problem that we already have 8 fairly active rogues.

smygelfh · Artifact

We've decided to decline this application for now, but you will be an obvious candidate if the situation changes when it comes to rogue activity.